Scott Postma

A blog about the Great Books, the Craft of Writing, and Human Flourishing.

What Constitutes Meaningful Art?

The philosopher and theologian, Francis Schaeffer, once said,

Unlike modern man, the men of the day did not live in a splintered world. Art was an intimate part of life. What is represented had more than an aesthetic value divorced from considerations of truth and religious significance.

Schaeffer reminds us that art reflects a particular worldview. In the same manner the art of the medieval man reflected his holistic worldview, the art of the modern man reflects his splintered, disconnected, compartmentalized view of the world. If each individual is his or her own source of truth, then anything and everything becomes art. Think Andy Warhol.

It would follow, it seems, that if everything is art, then, really, nothing is art. If the stuccoed track home is art the same way the grand architecture of an English manor is art, then beauty becomes subjective and arbitrary. And if beauty is subjective and arbitrary, then the word beauty has lost its meaning.

Speaking in terms of literary purpose, Horace asserted art is meant to enlighten and delight.

In a world where nothing is really art, because everything is art, and by definition beauty has no meaning, what is delightful and enlightening about art?

In a world where truth and religious significance is splintered, disconnected, and compartmentalized because all worldviews are equally meaningful, can art be considered meaningful?

(Visited 55 times, 1 visits today)

About Scott Postma

Scott is a writer and teacher living in North Idaho. He loves teaching the Great Books, writing and blogging, and collecting more books than he'll ever read in a lifetime. You can subscribe to the tribe and follow him on Twitter, Facebook, and Google Plus.

Subscribe for free, and get Write Like A Human, a resource that will teach you C.S. Lewis’s “secret sauce” for excellent writing. Plus, I’ll send you updates directly to your inbox every time I post.


Comments Policy: Comments that are relevant and add value to the conversation are encouraged, even if they express disagreement with the topic or the writer. All comments must be free from gross profanity, or otherwise distasteful language (at moderator’s discretion), and accompanied by a valid first name and email address (all anonymous comments are blocked).

2 Replies

  1. Laura Mc Coy

    I like your direction.

    1. Thanks, Laura. Do you have any thoughts on what makes meaningful art?